Everyone like to see a good refinishing job once in a while, right? I’m assuming so. Who wouldn’t? If someone said “Hey, I just refinished an antique dresser and it looks great, and it took a lot of work, do you want to see it?” who would say no? Only some giant jerkballoon. Certainly not you. You’re no jerkballoon.
So, would you like to see Shelly’s refinished dresser? Of course you would!
Here is where it started. Missing some handles, weathered and scuffed, and stained with an unfortunate orangey shade.
And here it is now! The wood looks better than new. So deep and glossy and 100% brought back to life.
But as you can see, when Shelly sent me this project, the handles hadn’t all been replaced yet. Don’t worry. For better or worse, I took the liberty of photoshopping a few options on it myself.
What do you think about these black antique scroll pulls? I thought they went with the keyhole hardware nicely, but maybe not a great option with the new silver knobs she already has on the top drawers.
What about ornate gold handles instead? Yay? Nay? Okay? Whattya say?
I think these silver cup pulls are a good choice to pair with the silver handles she already has. They look a little huge here, but that is the fault of the photoshop-ist.
Here is one last option: simple silver hanging pulls. Which one has your vote?
Shelly refinished this dresser for a friend, and estimates that it’s over 100 years old. The friend had already purchased a set new handles, but we may never know what they looked like, because they got stolen out of her car! Who steals dresser handles out of a car?? I think we all know the answer to that. JERKBALLOONS.
See more of Shelly’s refinishing process on her blog 100 Things 2 Do.










10 Comments
istuke
May 10, 2016 at 1:47 PMBeautiful improvement! The last option is my favorite. Simple choice that doesn’t fight the color and seems to go best with the style of the piece while still looking up-to-date.
Bertie DeWane
May 10, 2016 at 2:35 PMI also love the last option best! Beautiful refinishing job!!!
Ann
May 10, 2016 at 3:19 PMBeautiful job!
I would vote for the last handle option but think I would look at a black shade to match the locks to look more original or option 2 in black.
Fun post!
Ann
roberta
May 10, 2016 at 4:43 PMThe black antique scroll pulls are my pick. Beautiful finishing!
Shelly @100Things2Do
May 11, 2016 at 4:20 AMLindsay, I absolutely adore you – and not just because you made my dresser look so awesome (love the last set of handles), but because of your wit and originality. You are a true treasure and a blog I look forward to seeing each day. Xoxo
mercury
May 11, 2016 at 5:05 AMI have what I think is the exact dresser. It’s actually in my dining room, serving as a buffet. I inherited it from my Mom, who inherited it from her Aunt. It’s special to me, so I’m afraid to touch (ruin) it. I love the deeper color though and If I ever replace the handles, you’ve done the hard work for me! Great makeover.
Lil
May 11, 2016 at 5:42 AMI vote for the last choice. The cup handles just don’t go with the look of the dresser.
Reenie
May 11, 2016 at 8:45 AMDefinitely the gold handles. 🙂
Amy
May 11, 2016 at 2:30 PMJerkballoon. Love it. Last option has my vote too 🙂
Kimberly
May 15, 2016 at 5:16 AMI like the simple silver hanging pulls. Lovely job!